Heading into training camp, it was reasonable to think that the greatest concerns of the Los Angeles Chargers' season were going to lie on the margins of the roster.
Assuming that Mike McDaniel was able to implement some sort of consistent explosive quality to this offense, with a baseline of a viable passing and rushing attack, this team's ceiling was already projected to be higher than it was last season under Greg Roman. If Chris O'Leary could replicate even three quarters of Jess Minter's success, the thought was, this team could quickly become formidable on both sides of the ball.
But now Los Angeles sits at 0-5, keeping company at the bottom of the standings with the Tennesse Titans and Miami Dolphins. This, frankly, isn't a competitive squad, and almost every storyline we were monitoring at the start of the season has taken a back seat to the glaring reality of that fact.
Even if the inner hierarchy of the safety room won't lead the Chargers to the playoffs this season, though, it's still something worth monitoring as O'Leary continues to assert himself as Los Angeles' new defensive play caller. With Derwin James still week-to-week with a hamstring injury, the competition between Genesis Smith, RJ Mickens, and Tony Jefferson for snaps alongside Elijah Molden in the secondary has taken on a new complexion.
It's no longer the most intriguing storyline of the Chargers' season (if it ever truly was in the first place), but it's worth checking in on that competition as we round into the team's final pre-bye matchup.
Re-visiting the Chargers' safety battle as the defense continues to find its footing
The performance of the Chargers defense has actually been the one major silver lining that can be gleaned from this disastrous start to the season. Even with James and top cornerback Donte Jackson missing time, Los Angeles has still allowed the eighth-fewest passing yards in the league to this point in the season—a number which tracks relatively closely to where Minter's defenses sat in 2024 and 2025.
So let's focus on something positive for a change.
Heading into training camp, the Chargers had set the stage for an intriguing competition in the secondary by drafting ball-hawking safety Genesis Smith in the fourth round and bringing veteran Tony Jefferson back on a one-year deal. Theoretically, there would be limited snaps to go around between these players, as one safety spot has already been claimed by Elijah Molden and the other, at times, would be played by James. But both James and Molden have missed time to this point in the season, and here's how the snap share has shaken out among the Chargers' three complementary options in light of those developments:
Genesis Smith: 52% defensive snap share; 2 interceptions, 4 passes defended, 13 combined tackles
Tony Jefferson: 64% defensive snap share; 0 interceptions, 2 passes defended, 19 combined tackles
RJ Mickens: 43% defensive snap share (4 games); 0 interceptions; 0 passes defended, 9 combined tackles
Part of what made this competition so interesting entering the season is that each of these three pieces had true cases for claiming the bulk of snaps at the position, and that's born itself out in O'Leary's usage of the three safeties so far.
Genesis Smith flashed his ball-hawking and deep-field range during the preseason, and he's played the vast majority of his snaps as a free safety, although the split between run and passing defense reps is relatively clean. He also, notably, hasn't missed a tackle since the start of the season—a major development for a player who came into the draft with tackling concerns.
Jefferson, meanwhile, was not only a beloved piece of this roster but also a hard-hitting safety who could provide the Chargers with some extra physicality when they needed it. He's played a large portion of his snaps as a free safety as well, but he's gotten active as a downhill run defender multiple times over the past couple of games.
Mickens represented a solid middle ground in the competition. He was a viable piece in coverage last season after Alohi Gilman was traded to the Baltimore Ravens, and he has plenty of upside as a rotational safety. Of the three defenders, though, Mickens likely has the worst coverage metrics, depending on which categories you want to emphasize in evaluating that part of these players' games.
There was room for this hierarchy to take almost any shape at the start of the season, but it seems as though O'Leary has settled in pretty comfortably utilizing Jefferson as the team's primary safety next to Molden, slotting in Smith and then Mickens when the situation calls for it. Perhaps, when the secondary is whole again, Mickens will be the one to see his snap share cut.
But it's clear that this team has plenty of options to keep this room afloat this season, and that, at the very least, is an encouraging sign for O'Leary.
Add us as a preferred source on Google