To say the LA Chargers' Jake Slaughter selection is polarizing would be an understatement. Slaughter was considered a mid-round center prospect who the Chargers potentially reached for with the possible intention of playing at guard.
Slaughter never played guard in college and struggled in reps at the position during the Senior Bowl. There's a lot to like about his tape, but it's also not perfect. He's a great example of how if you watch just the best moments, he looks like a future All-Pro. If you watch just the worst, the pick looks awful.
Regardless of what side of the argument you fall on, GM Joe Hortiz and head coach Jim Harbaugh didn't do a great job justifying the pick when speaking to reporters after Day 2. Neither party confirmed that Slaughter would be the outright starting left guard, with Harbaugh even opening the door for him to be a glorified backup.
Based on the way this was phrased (in addition to Harbaugh calling him top C of the class):
— Alex Insdorf (@alexinsdorf99) April 25, 2026
It's more a center that can *potentially* play guard.
Possible he starts at LG day 1 over Penning-but Harbaugh said he was also comfortable with the idea of him at swing guard/IOL ("next… https://t.co/0M6uV0XNlo
Joe Hortiz and Jim Harbaugh do an awful job of selling Jake Slaughter to Chargers fans
It would be an abject failure if Slaughter loses the left guard battle in training camp and is a swing guard to start the season. Using a second-round pick on a backup, when there are legitimate starting holes to be filled, would be reprehensible.
It doesn't matter if Slaughter has long-term upside at that point. The Chargers need to draft players with upside who can also impact the team in 2026. That is what made the Akheem Mesidor selection so exciting in the first round; the Chargers were, without a doubt, going for it with a ready-to-bake NFL prospect.
The same can't be said about Slaughter, especially after these comments from Hortiz and Harbaugh. While he certainly should be the favorite to win the starting left guard position, who's to say that will actually happen? Based on these comments, there's a real chance that the Chargers just drafted a backup in round two.
And that alone highlights the entire issue with the pick itself. The Chargers drafted someone who the head coach and GM aren't even 100% sure will be a starter in his rookie season. That's fine with a fifth-round pick; it's not okay with a second-round pick.
If Slaughter is really that special, then there should be no doubts about his starting ability. And if there are concerns about his ability to play guard, well, maybe the Chargers should have taken an actual guard.
The hope is that this all works out and the Chargers end up with someone who has an impact right away while maintaining that exciting upside. It's hard to be overly ambitious about the best-case scenario after these comments, though.
Add us as a preferred source on Google