1. New York Giants week 14 - Throw of the year to Jalen Guyton for a 59 yard touchdown
Let's be real, when you first clicked on this article, you already knew this was going to be number one on the list. The 59 yard touchdown pass to Jalen Guyton was not only Herbert's best pass of the season, it's undisputedly the best throw by any quarterback across the league this year. On 3rd and 11, with 0:25 left in the first half, Herbert rolls to his right and gets off a rainbow throw just as he gets hit from his blindside. The pass travels 63.8 yards in the air and lands right in the breadbasket for his receiver, completing an out-of-this-world, once in a season level throw. These completions are why Herbert is already amongst the league's elite at the position.